Thursday

On Time and History


Some variations on the theme of time and history that accumulated over a long period of only reading Benjamin and Adorno.
On Time and History
I

Time - not as a concept but as a process through which events take place - exercises a peculiar form of violence on human beings. In time we forget, which is often a blessing, but thereby forfeit those thoughts and experiences which once defined us. Likewise, we may suddenly remember or, by some lengthy distillation of thought and circumstance, suddenly realize some long obscure fact about ourselves. In either case, what is lost or found is not just a bit of information or a tenuous mental image; a whole order of thought, experience and behavior begins to take new shape, however imperceptibly. As with the celestial revolutions, time alters the arrangement of these more intimate constellations through an elusive yet inevitable force.
II
The present does not advance or retreat; it stands still, obstinate, refusing to budge. And unlike the gaze we throw upon it, it reflects nothing, reveals nothing. The present is like matter: thoughtless, inert. But we are desire, restless before it. 

III
It is out of a great spirit of generosity that we're often ready to forgive ourselves our past transgressions. With the assurance that everything could always be different, that we could become different people, better people, we are provided perpetual consolation. 

The point at which our past is severed and life begins anew is a moment of miraculous instantaneity. Weeks, months and years are washed away in an instant. We preside over the last judgment of our own selves and, mercifully, find something left to be redeemed. 

But, to pass judgment on our selves, we must become other than ourselves. We must stand both beyond and before our selves. What can be seen from this dislocated perspective? Certainly not life, which remains obscure, as it is the occasion of the reflection itself. Life is only revealed as something to be judged at the time of death, the moment of its closure and completion. Thus, it seems that there is a fundamental misunderstanding between moments and lifetimes. Here, the part cannot know the whole by virtue of some common substance. It can only speculate as to what such a thing might consist of and, inevitably, hang some idol in its place. 

IV
In certain desperate moments, one's life can be reduced to ambition, memory and the perspicuous gap which comes between them. Ambition races ahead of memory to reveal a world in which the past is redeemed; but, memory lingers in the distance, surveying the ruins of past redemptions gone awry. The distance between memory and ambition, the past and its redemption, seems to open an impassable void. Experience, which is constituted in this void, is always facing, at one moment, forward, at another, back. In shifting from one pole to another, from ambition to memory, redemption to what is yet unredeemed, a certain attitude emerges, unhappily called despair. 

The idea of history can unravel this circuit, though not without certain strange effects. By conceding individual memory to universal history and individual ambition to history's obscure intent, one exchanges desperation for sublime indifference, desire for a sort of generalized compulsion. The striving and resistance which constitute life and vitality find new coordinates detached from the body and scattered throughout both space and time. From this perspective, one looks both before and beyond the grave, counted among the dead while walking among the living.

V

To stand toward History as the inheritor of every lost cause, of every revolution which betrayed its founding principles, of even those silent revolutions which were accomplished through the accumulation of actions which never anticipated their consequences - this is the height of nausea, of that vertigo which oscillates between cosmic insignificance and cosmic responsibility. It is an ethics which engenders hysteria, and sets in motion a feverish and restless mind. The act of remembrance becomes morbid, compulsive, obscuring the present with countless shadows. 

We can, and must, resist this pathology by latching onto the present, by keeping ourselves awake. But, the present carries its own vertigos, of which History is only one violent eddie. It's as if we have always to pinch ourselves and say, it's not just a dream.

VI
What can we say - in a very naive, psychological manner - is the value of History for us? Do we accumulate historical facts and anecdotes simply to furnish casual conversation or to arm ourselves in debate? Perhaps. But, neither of these purposes addresses what could rightfully be called the allure of History. History attracts us because it introduces an aura into the world. In learning the histories of our families, our cities, our country, we learn to see all around us the traces of human experience: devotion, expectation, struggle and abandonment. In this way, when we look out at the world our gaze is returned. We see in the mute materiality of buildings, streets, rivers and open country the specter of humanity which passed upon them — a humanity which, though estranged by the passage of time, is somehow still our own. Thus, History provides a sort of reconciliation with an alienated environment; it pierces the veil of opacity which hangs heavy on a modern world. 

VII

When is the present? We know that it is not a mathematical point in space, a dot on a finite or infinite line. Nor is it a delimited extension of consciousness into an endlessly emergent time. Empirically speaking, the present, as we experience it, is always already the past. What we perceive as present at hand is in fact the chimera of past experience. Our present seethes with memory. So the precise time of the present is impossible to locate. 

How, then, should we conceive of this moment? Is it the nexus of near infinite objective factors all interacting with imperceptible complexity? Or is it is the jagged relay of image and recollection, a circuit which plays time in its qualitative rather than its quantitative register? 

It seems as though the present must be antithetical to these abstractions. To abstract from the present is to lose the present itself. We encounter the present viscerally in moments of decisiveness, points at which time is catalyzed by the imminence of possible futures. The present seems always to announce itself, like an alarm bell, shaking us from an atemporal stupor. 

VIII

The past is a dangerous place. Many who go there return to the present armed with illusions. Because it is helpless to defend itself from our fantasies, history becomes the fodder for our myths, seductive narratives that transform the present and suggest an inevitable future. No history is innocent of such transgressions. To remember is always to revise, to change, to approach the past through the practical concerns, both conscious and unconscious, of the present. Knowing this to be the case, we should enter into the past with caution and even cunning, like refugees. The past is not our home, and to make it such would be to colonize an aura, to contain the effect of the past within the present. 

No comments:

Post a Comment